There’s just something about black denim. Casual and chic all at once, black jeans are built of an after-dark appeal that’s hard to pin down. Pair them with a white T-shirt and loafers and you have a classic model off-duty ensemble. Add an oversized leather jacket, and you’ve entered punk territory. But if you’re after the “perfect” pair, pay attention — according to celebrity fashion stylist Emily Gray, said concept is a myth. “It really depends on your body type, style preference, and the brand itself,” says Gray. “That being said, I do think the concept of the perfect jean does exist — it’s the style you feel the most confident in!”

Costume designer Johnetta Boone agrees — and as the go-to outfitter for Yellowstone, Boone knows her denim. “The best cut for the body type is the one that enhances the silhouette,” says Boone. “It’s so empowering to see jeans cut for every body type, well thought out and of quality.” From straight legs to flares, jet black to nearly gray, today’s black jeans are a study in variety — though if you ask celeb stylist Amanda Sanders, there are some universals. Rely on styles with a bit of elasticity, keep said jeans out of the dryer, and pay attention to the back pockets for the most flattering fit. 

Keep scrolling to discover PEOPLE’s picks for the best black jeans, plus more tips from Boone, Gray, and Sanders.